Is Christopher Nolan’s Odyssey true to the Homeric epic poem? Some highly regarded voices insist it is not. Others of at least equal qualification claim the opposite. I personally think they both are correct.
How is that possible? Before answering that, a similar dynamic about Waterloo:
Some teachers at High Tech High, a nation-leading innovative charter school in San Diego, mused that we might be the next step of innovative education. And, a woman who has helped people start classical Christian schools across Texas told me we might just be the next step in Classical education. We would have no problem if both ended up to be true.
How is that possible?
The world is really different than it has been in most of human history. Technology, culture, modern nation-states, scientific understanding—everything that makes modern life what it is is historically unique. On the other hand, the one thing that hasn’t changed is… we’re all still human. That is, as different as the world is, problems of wisdom, folly, justice, suffering, meaning, temptations, purpose, love—they’re still ‘things’, as much now as in say, the time of the Trojan War. We fight for what we believe and what we love… just as people always have. The more they change, one thing remains the same.
We would be stupid—it would be idiotic!—to not try to learn from the successes and failures of others—to even figure out whether what they thought was a success is something we think is. That’s a deeply classical and tradition-honoring education.
And we see a funny thing when we look to the past: everyone was always ever just trying to figure out how to live well—now and in the future. Regularly that included… innovating. (Trojan Horse, anyone?) Another way of saying this is that we don’t just learn from them: we are just doing what they were. Innovation, creativity, invention—these aren’t new at all.
Is Nolan’s telling of the story true to the way Homer told it? No, if we mean is Nolan’s film rooted in the values and exploring the issues of Homer’s ancient Greek world. Yes, if we mean is Nolan doing what Homer did, telling a well-known story in a way to advance values and explore issues of Nolan’s modern world.
Both are true, if we realize we have things to learn from the past—about what is really good and true—and if we commit not just to be nostalgic about that past, but actually draw from it that the challenge of living is living well, now and into the future.
